1905 Columbian Salad - Copycat Recipe

Chelsea Mills • July 26, 2020

Inspired by the 1905 Salad at the Columbia Restaurant in St. Augustine, FL.

“One Of America’s Top 10 Best Salads” - USA Today

In the 1970s, this flavorful salad was the Columbia’s answer to the ubiquitous salad bar. Created by waiter Tony Noriega in the 1940s, it was adapted by the Columbia, eventually phasing out the use of black olives and celery.

The Columbia kitchen designed a new dressing that features Worcestershire sauce, lemon, and Parmesan cheese. [When the president of Lea and Perrins heard that the Columbia was his biggest customer, he investigated and ate a “1905” Salad®. He soon discovered the salad’s delights for himself.]

This salad is amazing and paired perfectly with my Cuban Birthday Dinner!

INGREDIENTS

SALAD INGREDIENTS
  • 4 cups iceberg (I used Romaine) lettuce, broken into 1 ½" × 1 ½" pieces
  • 1 ripe tomato, cut into eighths
  • ½ cup baked ham, julienned 2" × ⅛" (may substitute turkey or shrimp)
  • ½ cup Swiss cheese, julienne 2" × ⅛"
  • ½ cup pimiento-stuffed green Spanish olives
  • ¼ cup Romano cheese, grated
  • 2 tablespoons Lea & Perrins Worcestershire Sauce®
  • 1 lemon
SALAD DRESSING INGREDIENTS
  • ½ cup extra-virgin Spanish olive oil
  • 4 garlic cloves, minced
  • 2 teaspoons dried oregano
  • ⅛ cup white wine vinegar
  • Salt and pepper to taste
DIRECTIONS
  1. Combine lettuce, tomato, ham, Swiss cheese and olives in a large salad bowl. Before serving, add “1905” Dressing, Romano cheese, Worcestershire and the juice of 1 lemon. Toss well and serve immediately. Makes 2 full salads or 4 side salads.
  2. Mix olive oil, garlic and oregano in a bowl with a wire whisk. Stir in vinegar, gradually beating to form an emulsion (I used an emulsifier), and then season with salt and pepper. For best results, prepare 1 to 2 days in advance and refrigerate. 
By Chelsea Mills October 14, 2024
Warm, buttery apple stacks with a cinnamon-sugar twist
By Chelsea Mills October 5, 2024
Fun weekend breakfast bake
By Chelsea Mills September 29, 2024
A fluffy, citrus-kissed blueberry Dutch Baby topped with lemon curd
By Chelsea Mills September 29, 2024
Italian twist on a Frittata bake
By Chelsea Mills September 22, 2024
A cozy dip for date night
By Chelsea Mills September 11, 2024
Peanut Butter & Nutella Skillet Cookie: A Dreamy Duo in Every Bite
By Chelsea Mills September 11, 2024
Mini Cast Iron Skillet Chocolate Chip Cookies: A Sweet Treat with a Special Twist
By Chelsea Mills February 12, 2023
This recipe I created from looking up various pizza twist recipes. The inspiration comes from the Boston's pizza twists.
By Chelsea Mills December 17, 2022
From Mario Batali's NY Restaurant BABBO
Prosciutto-Wrapped Pork With Sweet Potatoes & Pears
By Chelsea Mills October 20, 2020
This is a recipe I found in 2011 from Real Simple and thought sounded fantastic. I finally got around to making it and it was incredibly easy and tasted wonderful too.
More Posts
Share by: